About hospitalimpact.org

Join our online community!

Latest Posts



Hospital Leadership Series


Hot Topics

  • Last comments
  • Subscribe to this blog!



    Subscribe in NewsGator Online

    Hospital Impact can also be seen through:

    Hospital Strategy Revisited

    July 3rd, 2007

    guest post by Jeff McKune

    Andrew touched on the central point of strategy when he said that it is "where you want to be." As with solving any problem, understanding the problem is the first step. Understanding where a hospital wants to be in the future is the first step in strategy development. There is a strategy development methodology known as complex adaptive systems that overcomes some of the shortcomings to other approaches. None would question that the healthcare industry is dynamic, with players and variables changing so quickly that adapting a static approach to strategy development is, for all practical purposes, hopeless. Perhaps those more static methodologies, and the resulting frustrations, are one of the reasons why senior leadership often reverts to a more operationally focused "what do we need today" approach.

    In brief, the complex adaptive systems methodology starts simply with a series of scenarios. Write several brief scenarios about aspects of healthcare in the future - just a few paragraphs for each is sufficient. Base each scenario on your current knowledge as well as trends that you see. Where will healthcare be in five or ten years? Write in the present tense, placing yourself in the new world of healthcare as if it actually existed. Select two or three of the most compelling scenarios as the seeds of your strategy. From here, the strategy development is a series of straightforward but thoughtful steps.

    * Identify the stakeholders in your scenarios. What skills and capabilities do they have? How will your organization relate to them?
    * The keystone organization is that organization through which other services will flow. It is the cornerstone of the socioeconomic business system - the healthcare environment in which you operate. What skills, capabilities, equipment, and other resources will you need to be that keystone organization in your scenario? Do you have the right people? This will hopefully lead to another entirely separate discussion on strategic human resources management.
    * Decide how you will acquire the skills, capabilities, resources, equipment, and people that you will need. This is much more than "we need a 64 slice CT scanner". This is acquisition with intent and a clear view of where the acquisitions will place you in your future scenario.
    * The plan for acquiring what you will need becomes an action plan that is the basis for your implementation plan for your strategy. Implementation is where so many organizations fall short, so developing project plans and milestones is crucial.

    At least once a year, revisit your scenarios. What has changed? How have the complexities of your system reshaped your scenario? Simply restate your scenario and reiterate through the steps once again. What you learned from the previous effort and your new perspectives will sharpen your next strategic plan. This is the advantage to the complex adaptive systems approach.

    When your entire organization is focused on making your hospital successful five or ten years in the future, it is much more difficult for other organizations to compete or deflect you from your target. It is like playing chess with someone who can think ten moves ahead of you - you don't stand a chance.

    Jeff is Director of the Ambulatory Surgery Unit at Phelps County Regional Medical Center

    Comments, Pingbacks:

    Comment from: Carolyn Kent [Visitor] · http://www.hospitaldx.com
    "When your entire organization is focused on making your hospital successful five or ten years in the future, it is much more difficult for other organizations to compete or deflect you from your target."

    I'm reminded of Porter's 5 Forces. In a dynamic industry with intense rivalry, the only way to thrive is to develop some sort of sustainable competitive advantage that will drive a wide "capability gap" between your hospital and your competitors.

    But is that really what we want for the hospital industry? More intense competition that could potentially drive other providers out of business? Or is this an industry in which we want fierce competition to subside in the interest of having an array of market providers that are able to deliver affordable, high-quality care to consumers?

    Then again, a hospital IS a business and one of its primary objectives is to make money so that it can continue to serve its market... operating in a highly competitive manner (in a way that continues to widen that capability gap over time) may be the best (and only) strategy for doing so.
    Permalink 07/03/07 @ 10:57
    Comment from: Jeff McKune [Visitor] · http://www.pcrmc.com
    Carolyn raises a very valid point. Does being successful with a powerful strategy necessarily mean that we obliterate the competition? As she asked, "...is that what we really want for the hospital industry?"

    Moving your organization into that keystone position in your socioeconomic business system does not mean that your organization is the only player. But it does mean that your organization becomes the pivot point, or using another metaphor - the pipeline, for health care services. In more concrete terms, becoming the keystone organization means that physicians would rather affiliate with you than some other organization, patients prefer your care over that of others, you are in a position to negotiate better contracts with insurance companies, and you are a trusted and integral part of life in the community.

    In that position, it is quite possible that forming alliances, cooperative agreements, or carve-outs with former competitors can actually become advantageous. Another indicator of a strong keystone organization is the formation of specialized niche businesses around that organization.

    Carolyn is correct in her statement. The old position that "This town ain't big enough for the both of us" is not likely to serve the industry well.
    Permalink 07/04/07 @ 10:13
    Comment from: Lavinia Weissman [Visitor] · http://www.workecology.com
    Clem Bezold and many other futurists in the late 80's and early 90's predicted that the number of hospital beds would significantly reduce. I do not believe that is the case and I have not had time to do this analysis.

    It is very very difficult to take a group of people in a hospital and undo years of success and build an innovation. Plaintree has done it to a certain degree.

    I am currently writing and reworking a future scenario that is not hospital dependent.

    By nature of this blog and its name, HOSPITAL IMPACT, we have here many many people who work in hosptials, who I am certain want to keep their jobs. The real shift changers in health care will focus on what can happen outside the hospital.

    To date, I have not see any hospital use a methodology from Gareth Morgan where you imagine your future by forecasting a future that considers other environmental facts on your landscape. In this instance, when I use the word "environment," I speak to the external influences such as policy, innovation, elder care, pediatric trends, etc and much more that factor into defining what in the future a hospital will do and how that changes the roles in tasks.

    For example, in a future---a palliative care unit may actually work to facilitate conversations with patients to make choices about how they want to die and how the family wants to be involved. To an extent, Sloan Kettering and Duke do this now. However, palliative care is complex and in my mind based on the learning taught by the Metta Institute, www.mettainstitute.org, a very different future will be in place for hospitals with respect to palliative care.

    Thank you for starting this topic. Through the years I have authored or facilitated many different scenarios and found hospital administrators have death ears to what is possible and the changing trends at the frontier that so many want to adopt that are often sabotaged by IT and Lawyers and top down appraoches.
    Permalink 07/05/07 @ 01:03

    Leave a comment:

    Your email address will not be displayed on this site.
    Your URL will be displayed.
    Allowed XHTML tags: <p, ul, ol, li, dl, dt, dd, address, blockquote, ins, del, a, span, bdo, br, em, strong, dfn, code, samp, kdb, var, cite, abbr, acronym, q, sub, sup, tt, i, b, big, small>
    URLs, email, AIM and ICQs will be converted automatically.


    authimage

    Options:
     
    (Line breaks become <br />)
    (Set cookies for name, email & url)

    Google
     

    Get Hospital Impact in your inbox!

    Enter your Email

    Preview