FierceEMR FierceMobileHealthcare

Wikio - Top Blogs - Health

January 27, 2010 -- Hospital Impact has been ranked one of the top 50 healthcare blogs by Wikio.

About hospitalimpact.org

Join our online community!

Latest Posts



Hospital Leadership Series


Hot Topics

  • Last comments
  • Subscribe to this blog!



    Subscribe in NewsGator Online

    Misc

    The Passive Agressive Organization

    April 23rd, 2007

    by Nick Jacobs

    In an October 1, 2005 article in the Harvard Business Review, "The Passive Aggressive Organization" by Gary L. Neilson, Bruce Pasternack and Karen E Van Nuys, we learn about the characteristics of, you guessed it, passive aggressive organizations. My immediate response to the article was something like this, "Wow, this sounds exactly like a lot of the places where I have worked." (And some of the places where I work now.) For your sake, go online and buy it for $6 because what you'll be reading here is my version of a summary that surely won't do it justice.

    When you observe a few of these symptoms in your organization, you surely will know where you are working:

    7 Traits of a Highly Passive-Aggressive Organization

    1. Senior management leaves unclear lines as to where accountability lies.

    2. Employees put forth only enough effort to look compliant.

    3. Managers are absolved for almost anything they do.

    4. Employees wait interminably for a "project go ahead," and then their actions are accompanied by a sea of second guessing.

    5. To learn, to share and to achieve are actions that are not encouraged.

    6. There is either too much or too little control at the top.

    7. Employees can't understand why their promising projects can't get traction.

    The article goes on to say that the lack of confrontation is only a disguise for intransigence. In many companies a failure to align incentives and goals is generally seen as a primary contributor to this culture. It further states that the observer will frequently see agreement without co-operation which leads to the impression of compliance.

    It's also clear that leadership is POOR at completing employee evaluations, and, in many companies, the failure to align incentives with goals is rampant.

    So, you might ask, how can this culture be fixed?

    Leadership must identify, verify and admit that they have a problem, and then work in a dedicated fashion to address each of the symptoms delineated above.

    The article recommends bringing in an outsider, the new sheriff in town. It also suggests creating a team of seven up and comers who are assigned the seven most important tasks needed to be accomplished during a turn around. This team must be empowered by the senior leadership members, and be permitted to fly.

    It's not easy. It's not necessarily fast, and if it's not addressed, it will take the organization to the brink of failure. So, good luck.

    Comments, Pingbacks:

    Comment from: Nick Jacobs [Visitor] · http://windberblog.typepad.com
    I'm thrilled to report that this post was NOT about our hospital, but I absolutely agree with everything you said in your comments. Nick
    Permalink 04/23/07 @ 15:55
    Comment from: Lavinia Weissman [Visitor] · http://www.workecology.com
    Bruce Pasternack and his cadre are excellent. They are with Booz Allen and Hamilton, so enjoy these free sharing articles from Strategy + Business or with a FREE subscription you can search on Bruce Pasternack at the S+B Website:




    1. The Four Bases of Organizational DNA
    By Gary Neilson, Bruce A. Pasternack, and Decio Mendes

    Trait by trait, companies can evolve their own execution cultures.

    http://www.strategy-business.com/press/article/03406?pg=all

    2.A Global Checkup: Diagnosing the Health of Today’s Organizations
    By DeAnne M. Aguirre, Lloyd W. Howell Jr., David B. Kletter, and Gary L. Neilson

    11/17/05
    A new Booz Allen Hamilton study detects the sources of organizational dysfunction and reveals where you’re most likely to find companies programmed to thrive.
    http://www.strategy-business.com/resiliencereport/resilience/rr00026?pg=0


    3. Profiles in Organizational DNA Research and Remedies
    By Gary Neilson, Bruce Pasternack, Decio Mendes, and Eng-Ming Tan

    2/04/04

    http://www.strategy-business.com/resiliencereport/resilience/rr00004?pg=0
    Permalink 04/23/07 @ 19:18
    Comment from: Lavinia Weissman [Visitor] · http://www.workecology.com
    I want to also talk about my own experience with passive organizations in health care.

    4 years ago, I began working with www.clinicalfocus.com. I act as their VP of Strategy on a part-time basis. We developed a technological tool and had signed letters of intent, we could present to angel investors on using this tool from a number of hospitals.

    We got bogged down in the passive and mechanical practice and interference that emerges within hospitals that ties to legal talking to medical records, medical records feeling like they want included in the decision and more hub bub. I am not describing facts because on a people basis, everyone's intentions were excellent.

    Similar to this experience when I returned to Boston in 1999 and began to talk to old colleagues from my former employer (the local HMO) I saw passivity in action I had never seen before.

    I have become more active with Clinical Focus recently, because my ideas seem to be timely. We are now building cooperation with groups outside of hospitals that actually want to impact patient care. What is also key is how we engage in conversation. We simply no longer offer what we have (the big secret weapon for health care, I say with humor) to people who accept working in a mechanical way as the only way to work and are not people who want to innovate change in health care.

    Its hard to do that when you are in a full time job. I would not want anyone including Nick to give up their paycheck. However, I keep asking myself how do people I respect like Nick and Tony fly with innovation in systems that are often passive and relying on technology and methods of practice they won't question or change?

    That's my rant for today.
    Permalink 04/23/07 @ 19:24
    Comment from: hospitaltony [Member]
    based on the "symptoms" listed above, it seems like it takes just a few passive aggressive leaders to turn the organization passive aggressive. All the more reason to hire the right people.
    Permalink 04/23/07 @ 21:00
    Comment from: Dave Woolley [Visitor]
    I agree with both the Mr. Jacobs and Ms. Young that many hospitals can be classified passive-aggressive (PA) organizations where more energy is put into thwarting change than starting it, but in the nicest way possible.

    That PA label, by itself, is unfair for hospitals because of three systemic cultural norms that are dominant in hospitals:

    1. RISK AVERSION: Their mission involves life and death decisions where the consequences of some errors can be catastrophic to the patient, the care providers and the hospital. In that environment, less effective managers and organizations prefer to 'bury their mistakes' as opposed to celebrate them or ‘to learn, to share, to achieve.'

    2. SPECIALIZATION AND RATE OF CHANGE: For over half a century medicine has become increasingly specialized and the rate of knowledge aggregation has continued to accelerate. In that environment, each functional area or program becomes a knowledge silo where the person with the most degrees and years of experience tends to control process design and service delivery standards. If that person is not flexible and current, people below the leader ‘put forth only enough effort to look compliant.’ Further is that since people in one program area quickly learn that they do not understand the complexities of the jobs in other program areas, collegiality and mutual respect are encouraged while criticism or negative feedback is discouraged.

    3. UNIQUE ROLE OF THE DOCTOR: Many observers expect that the most expensive resources in the hospital are the high cost assets such as the diagnostic imaging equipment – CAT scanners, MRIs – or the operating room. Experienced administrators and doctors both agree that the most expensive asset in the hospital is the doctor’s pen. What the doctor does or does not write for patient will determine if the patient stays two days or six days, if the patient will or will not have complications that could cost thousands of dollars to resolve, and even if the patient will require hospitalization at all. In no other industry is the person who determines 60 to 70% of the organization’s costs and resource utilization typically an outside contractor who is not paid by the organization or controlled by the CEO.

    With this type of ‘unclear lines as to where accountability lies’ for cost and quality outcomes, it is no wonder that hospital manager and staff often exhibit passive-aggressive behaviour.

    The solution the original authors, three Booz, Allen Hamilton consultants, suggest is a little more comprehensive than a new sheriff and seven deputies as project managers.

    We are making many of the mistakes in health care that we made with steel industry in the seventies; continued with electronics manufacturing in the eighties; repeated with airlines in the nineties; and continue today with automotive manufacturers. Mistakes don’t get any prettier the fourth and fifth time around. In these chronically ailing industries, less effective management teams tried to grow their way to greatness by merging (i.e., buying someone else’s customers or technology) and across-the-board cost cutting involving reduced customer service, staff complement, wages, benefits or outsourcing. The stresses of continual well-intentioned but poorly-executed reorganizations and cost cutting programs will eventual turn the most dedicated employees and managers into ‘deserters’ or passive-aggressive resistors of change.

    The only organizations in these four terminally-ill industries who grew and prospered have done so with constant focus on the customer’s needs and wants (e.g., autos – Toyota; airlines - Southwest), constant innovation both in products and services or supply chain processes (e.g., steel – Nucor, electronics – Dell, RIM); having clear performance outcomes (e.g., British Airways or BA); sharing performance data with employees; and empowering their front line staff to own and change their processes to reduce waste, errors and delays.

    When hospitals focus on the patient; empower staff to continually drive waste, errors and delay from the care pathways (not just the administrative support processes); and align patient / hospital and doctors goals there can be quantum leaps in quality, productivity, satisfaction and cost reductions.

    Mr. Jacobs is correct that transforming the organization is not quick. While bringing in a new ‘sheriff’ or leader may be required, that solution is not without risk. More common and less risky is when senior management recognizes the current service delivery model, care pathways and strategies are no longer working effectively; and they lack the experience or resources to do the redesign and implementation. The change can be led by the existing management team if they get experienced help through consultants, selective recruiting and management development. The transformation of passive-aggressive organization involves many skills and disciplines: designing robust processes, clarifying roles, performance management systems that provide the transparent quality, cost and productivity data required, realigning rewards and recognition programs, etc. However in 12 to 36 months, anyone that has been through the successful transformation to a stronger ‘resilient’ organization will agree the investment was both critical to survival but one of the best investment decisions the organization ever made.
    Permalink 04/23/07 @ 23:21
    Comment from: Lavinia Weissman [Visitor] · http://www.workecology.com
    Hi Hospital Tony, you seem renewed in energy. The baby must be sleeping through the night now.

    I beg to differ with you. I know many organizations that hire "the right people."

    I think it really ties to what http://www.workecology.com is about as a thought leadership group when we ask the question, "Who really matters?" Which core group matters and who in the core group dictates what matters?

    This is not simple now in the world of social network, free agents and the disparity of so many groups of professionals and how they organize to work with each other in health care.

    Health care as a confusing sector (profit/non profit, et.c0 and hospitals as institutions have a very complex social network from which to draw talent, serve the patient and work with the limitations of the infrastructure that forces decisions in a direction that is not what people want.

    I am starting to believe the best thing I can do now is to go out and teach Systems Thinking to groups of people cross practice, expertise and institution to learn how mechanical systemsfreeze the possibility of what the right people actually know what to do.

    And in that regard then look at the financial issues and how to empower change within that structure.

    Have a pleasant day all. If anyone would like to view a drawing of the systems at work and the cause and affect in practice, write me and I'll send you a diagram that I use to invite people into conversations from which to lead for change.
    Permalink 04/24/07 @ 14:09
    Comment from: hospitaltony [Member]
    as always, very insightful comments, Lavinia. and thanks noticing my 2nd (err. probably 8th) wind on the blog here.

    I guess I would agree with Jim Collins who says that it's more important to "get the right people on the bus" and THEN "figure out where to go" after that. With the right people, it's that much easier to model the right culture, think the right way (including systems thinking), and go the right way.
    Permalink 04/24/07 @ 14:29
    Comment from: markweee [Visitor]
    Dude, these were awesome! Just downloaded the pack and looking forward for more. I can't get to your 1st set of brushes, though. Something wrong with the link? Still, cool post. Thanks! ME degree AND Information Technology Diploma
    Permalink 10/15/09 @ 07:08
    Comment from: markweee [Visitor]
    The fact that they are free is even better. With more people using photoshop your generosity is greatly appreciated. Excellent work and kudos for being willing to share them to anyone who is interested to try them. Criminal Justice school AND PhD computer science AND computer school
    Permalink 10/15/09 @ 07:09
    Comment from: Yaron Cheng [Visitor]
    The fashion guru behind the Ed Hardy and Christian Audigier ,Ed Hardy clothinglines was Jackson's landlord during the final months of his life
    Permalink 11/05/09 @ 21:34
    Comment from: Cheng [Visitor]
    In small groups (maximum 8 People) and with a flexible schedule Japan tour will show you the best of Japan while also giving you the freedom to explore by yourself.Nantong FRP Products frp grating, Ltd is an entity professionalized in producing and selling FRP grids, plastic molded grids and drawing and crowding type of material.
    Permalink 11/05/09 @ 21:35
    Comment from: Ronald Pettigrew [Visitor]
    I've heard this about 100 times - issues with hospitals (especially city hospitals) are slow to get resolved if they ever do. Most of the time they don't.

    affordable online degree programs
    / accredited online colleges / top online schools
    Permalink 11/17/09 @ 14:36
    Comment from: abercrombie and fitch [Visitor] · http://www.abercrombieandfitchclub.com
    Fitch store in general abercrombie and fitch , everything a good matrimony before marriage have nothing to retain the preceding "female mad batch - abercrombie" part of the two is the first home in new york city a horde promotion sportswear for men and it is a successful lawyer, that is, ezra fitch.Ezra fitch in a charge over a very intricate to read from the abercrombie is obstinate to read and long abercrombie & fitch. He's also very good brand hollister, including abercrombie mens and abercrombie womens, abercrombie hollister, Ruehl No.925. Has become a fashionable personage's first choice, abercrombie outlet is all over the world, of course, is also expected to 2009 New Arrivals
    Permalink 12/05/09 @ 02:01
    Comment from: domuz gribi aşısı [Visitor] · http://www.google.com.tr
    Thank you very much for this information.
    Good post thanks for sharing.
    I like this site ;)
    -----------
    ps3 oyun takas ps3 oyun takas
    batman batman
    domuz gribi asisi domuz gribi asisi
    oyun oyna oyun oyna
    cam balkon cam balkon
    film izle film izle
    ic mimari ic mimari
    cerceve cerceve
    fizik tedavi fizik tedavi

    celik kapi celik kapi


    -----------

    Permalink 12/26/09 @ 05:21
    Comment from: coetsee [Visitor]
    Affiliate Marketing is a performance based sales technique used by companies to expand their reach into the internet at low costs. This commission based program allows affiliate marketers to place ads on their websites or other advertising efforts such as email distribution in exchange for payment of a small commission when a sale results.

    www.onlineuniversalwork.com
    Permalink 01/14/10 @ 07:12
    Comment from: leader [Visitor]
    Thank you very much for this information.
    Nice Article Thank You
    I like this site ;)
    oyun hileleri
    savas oyunlari
    free online games
    msn nickleri
    hiz oyunlari
    oyun oyna
    18 oyunlar
    dis hastaliklari
    sxe injected
    video izle
    18 oyunlar
    Permalink 01/23/10 @ 16:17
    Comment from: snap [Visitor] · http://www.sunrisecapital.com.pk/

    Have a look….
    kse
    srt

    Permalink 02/04/10 @ 01:47
    Comment from: M.asad [Visitor] · http://www.googlesearch.co.cc/
    Permalink 02/07/10 @ 09:03

    Leave a comment:

    Your email address will not be displayed on this site.
    Your URL will be displayed.
    Allowed XHTML tags: <p, ul, ol, li, dl, dt, dd, address, blockquote, ins, del, a, span, bdo, br, em, strong, dfn, code, samp, kdb, var, cite, abbr, acronym, q, sub, sup, tt, i, b, big, small>
    URLs, email, AIM and ICQs will be converted automatically.


    authimage

    Options:
     
    (Line breaks become <br />)
    (Set cookies for name, email & url)

    Google
     

    Get Hospital Impact in your inbox!

    Enter your Email

    Preview

    Safety Tip

    Hospital facilities built today do not include asbestos, but many older buildings still have asbestos components in them. Steam pipes, boilers and furnace ducts were often insulated with an asbestos blanket or asbestos paper tape because of their fireproof and insulating properties. Resilient floor tiles were made from vinyl asbestos. Asbestos cement was employed in roofing, shingles and siding materials. The hazard of this carcinogen increases when the fibers become airborne, and untrained contractors can inadvertently increase risks by cutting, tearing, sawing, scraping, or sanding asbestos materials. Elevated asbestos levels can occur in hospitals where old materials are damaged or disturbed. It is best to leave undamaged asbestos material alone if it is not likely to be disturbed. Inhaling asbestos fibers is known to cause mesothelioma and other diseases. Be sure to use an experienced asbestos removal contractor when you need to get rid of old materials that might contain asbestos.